
The Book
Lev Grossman's The Magicians is often described as a grown-up Harry Potter, with a strong dose of Narnia thrown in. It's true, there is a school of magic and a big bad, a fantasy land from childhood stories that turns out to be real, and a bunch of young adults figuring out life against this backdrop. But The Magicians is so much more--it's an exploration of what it means to get what you've always wanted, the life you always thought SHOULD be yours but somehow wasn't, and what that does to your head when it's still not enough to make you happy. The basic premise: magic is real, and there are colleges all around the world that take in those most suited to the academic discipline and rigor required to learn it. Quentin Coldwater, a dissatisfied, mildly clinically depressed, and intellectually gifted high school senior thinks he's on his way to an admissions interview with a Princeton alumnus. Instead, he and his best friend James find the old man dead, and the strange paramedic who arrives hands them each an envelope that changes everything. Quentin finds himself transported to Brakebills College for Magical Pedagogy, and after an intense entrance exam comes to understand that what he secretly longed for his entire life (magic is REAL) is now his. See, in his heart of hearts, Quentin never stopped believing in the possibility that he might someday get his Hogwarts letter, or find the door in the wardrobe, or enter the world in the walls, this universe's Narnia analog, Fillory.Reviewing this without spoiling either the books or the show is really challenging. I guess I will start by going on record as something of a purist when it comes to page-to screen translations (ask anyone who's had to sit next to me during any of the Harry Potter movies), but I also can admit when the screen does it better. There are plenty of examples--Jaws and Jurassic Park both were better in movie form, most anything adapted from a Phillip K Dick short story is a better, if somewhat cheesier, experience on screen. But The Magicians has some fundamental problems that are hard for me to accept. There are a lot of changes to characters for the sake of sexing things up. I actually loved that a lot of the sexuality in the novels is kind of awkward and somewhat dysfunctional. That's a realistic portrayal of college life. Instead, many of the characters have been made over into super hot, super confident, and very well dressed babes. Not inherently bad as there is still substance to the story, but it does impact character development in some major ways.
The two main issues I have with the show are its handling of a certain "romantic" entanglement that leads to major, major consequences, and it's treatment of a secondary character in book one, Julia. In The Magicians, Julia also took the Brakebills entrance exam, but didn't pass. The protocol for students who fail is a memory wipe. In Julia's case, it doesn't completely take, and that causes a rift in her consciousness where the false memories are constantly arguing with the real ones and slowly breaking her mind. In book two, The Magician King, the parallel stories of main character Quentin's present, and Julia's past, take the story in an even darker direction, as we follow Julia's path from Brakebills reject to a powerful "hedge witch". Her magic is hard won in the underground safe houses filled with people like her, who know magic is real but for various reasons have been denied access to its official institutions. This also makes her magic wild, rough around the edges, unrefined, and therefore extremely powerful. TV Julia was Quentin's best friend since childhood, Book Julia, on the other hand, is Quentin's unrequited crush, and his best friend James' girlfriend. This makes book Julia's search for Quentin, to force someone to admit to her she's not crazy, much more intense and poignant. And her journey after she gets that proof is much more drawn out, and ultimately more satisfying and intense. TV Julia figures out pretty fast how to find Quentin, and how to find other people like her. She falls in with a rebellious crowd led by a caricature of a villain who was not in the books, and although after her adventures with that crew there are some parallels with her book-self, her character's arc lacks the emotional punch of the written version. Emotional punch is what's lacking with the romantic entanglement as well--in the show, the reasons for bad behavior are far more excusable so the emotional betrayal is not as believable.
All in all, the show is still entertaining and Hale Appleman as Quentin's snarky, wine swilling, somewhat trampy new friend and ultimately roommate, is absolutely perfectly cast and one of the highlights of the show.
Significant Moment in Food
"Dinner's almost ready," the girl said. "Eliot's made an amatriciana sauce. We couldn't get any guanciale, but I think bacon works fine. Don't you?"When Quentin and Alice first enter the cottage of the Physical Kids--that is, the students whose magical discipline is physical magic--Quentin finally thinks he's made it. There are books and wine everywhere, artifacts and curios scattered around, and a casually elegant vibe throughout the space. The three other occupants, Eliot, Janet (Margot on TV), and Josh, have that tight-knit insider, gossipy friendship that Quentin craves. Quentin feels that he has finally stepped into the empty place that's been waiting for him all these years. His old, false life is over. "He was in the warm heart of the secret world", Grossman writes. Quentin and Alice have essentially walked in to an adult dinner party and the choice of amatriciana, which is simple, classic, yet luxurious and sophisticated, is a specific prop to further illustrate this graduation into the next phase.
The Recipe
Amatriciana is a classic Italian sauce based on three key components--salty, fatty guanciale (cured pork cheek), acidic tomatoes, and sharp pecorino cheese. It hails from an area east of Rome called Amatrice, and like most of the old Italian recipes, it is a simple preparation focused on specific quality ingredients and how they interact with each other. The preferred pasta seems to be bucatini, but spaghetti is often substituted. Like many old, regional recipes, there are numerous variations and plenty of things done in one locality that are unacceptable in others. Other optional ingredients are hot chili peppers, parsley, white wine, and onions.To break it down and make it as Eliot did, I had to take some guesses. We know he used bacon instead of the traditional guanciale, and not much else. For that reason, I stuck to the basics repeated in each recipe I reviewed. Bacon, diced and sauteed to render the fat; garlic; and peeled tomatoes you crush by hand into the pan. Eliot DOES add wine to the pan, however, the scene in the book mentions several bottles of red wine empty on the floor, and Janet pours out the last of it for Quentin and Alice. All the recipes I found that used wine used a dry white. I used red and followed Eliot's advice "Never cook with a wine you wouldn't drink". I used something far less classy but certainly drinkable, that's right--BOTA BOX (don't judge me). And lastly, Eliot adds a generous glug of cream to the sauce. In my research I didn't come across a single recipe that took this step, but I'm making Eliot's Amatriciana, so I went with it. I cheated further by using turkey bacon. This is not for health reasons but rather that my husband absolutely loathes pork bacon, and the smell alone makes him sick. I still nurse some random vegetarian proclivities and can't really bring myself to eat pork most of the time. I have tried many brands of turkey bacon and for fattiness/crispiness I prefer Butterball. You need fatty richness, acidic tomato, and sharp pungent cheese to really get to the heart of amatriciana.
Ingredients
12 oz bacon, diced (your choice of cured plant or animal)28 oz peeled plum tomatoes, preferably imported Italian
3 cloves garlic, smashed whole
1-2 tablespoons olive oil
Pecorino Romano cheese--1 oz or more if you like it cheesy
A slosh of red wine
A generous glug of cream
It goes without saying that you should be boiling water and cooking your pasta of choice while preparing the sauce. Fresh, dried, whatever you want. I used plain old spaghetti.
Method
1. Heat olive oil in a large saucepan. Add bacon. Saute until much of the fat is rendered and bacon is lightly browned. Remove bacon and set aside, leaving most of the rendered fat in the pan.
4. Add a glug of cream. I don't know what a glug is technically--in the book the sauce "thickened and paled", I probably added about 4 oz.
5. Add your cooked pasta to the pan and allow to finish cooking for another few minutes. Stir to coat each piece of pasta in the sauce.
6. Serve in bowls and top with as much pecorino as you can handle!

Delicioso! Smoky, sharp, tangy and creamy heaven. We ALL loved this dish and with one pound of pasta we had enough for dinner with seconds for 3 of us, plus lunch the next day.
I hope you enjoy! Next up will be a guest post from my junior chef in training!
Credit and thanks to research sources Serious Eats, Mario Batali, Good Old Wikipedia, and the New York Times.